Top Defences in Criminal Cases | What Every Sydney Resident Should Know?
Introduction
It can be quite intimidating to have to face criminal charges. However, the best way to protect yourself in such a situation is to properly understand your legal rights and have a solid criminal defence. Anyone accused of a crime in Sydney is entitled to a fair trial, and it is assumed that they are innocent until proven otherwise.
In this blog, we try to understand the Sydney legal defence in detail and how effective defences can potentially help reduce penalties, challenge the case of the prosecution, or even result in acquittal.
The Basics of Criminal Defence in Sydney
What does a criminal defence in Sydney entail? All defence options revolve around the rights protection of individuals and ensuring everyone gets a fair trial. A criminal defence lawyer usually challenges the case of the prosecution, highlighting procedural errors or presenting alternate explanations. It includes the presumption of innocence, burden of proof, and legal framework. Common types of defences include mistaken identity, self-defence, alibi, and lack of intent. Moreover, under the legal framework, criminal laws outline both defences and offences in detail.
It is important to note here that an effective criminal defence involves understanding the case and the applicable laws in detail to then devise a strategic plan with the help of an experienced counsel.
4 Top Defences in Criminal Cases
1) Self-Defence
The most common defence that is often invoked in criminal cases is self-defence. This defence can usually be witnessed in violent offences like assault. It usually applies when a person protects themselves from an imminent threat using justifiable force. They could also be protecting their property or someone else for self-defence to be applicable. It is usually demonstrated when there is an imminent threat, honest belief, proportionate response, and objective reasonableness involved. Self-defence can even result in acquittal if successfully argued.
2) Lack of Intent (Mens Rea)
Lack of intent or mens rea is considered a crucial protection in criminal law. If there is a lack of criminal intent then it is unfair to subject the person to a criminal punishment unless it results from reckless behavior. In essence, Mens Rea states that only people who are sufficiently aware of their acts and their consequences must face a criminal procedure. Hence, if a case is argued well on the basis of Mens Rea, the person can be acquitted completely.
3) Duress or Coercion
Duress defence is not a justification of a crime but an excuse for committing a crime. In such cases, the defendants need to showcase that even the most logical person would have done the same thing if they were in a similar situation. They need to demonstrate that there was an element of coercion in crime and that the defendant had no alternative but to commit that crime. However, the defendant is required to show clear evidence to prove coercion.
4) Insanity or Mental Incapacity
Insanity defence can be used by defendants if they can prove that they were going through a mental illness or cognitive impairment at the time of committing the crime. Mental incapacity defence showcases that the person did not have any idea about the quality or nature of their act and its effect on another person or the society. In such cases, the defendants can make a strong case based on their mental illness.
Conclusion
To sum up, these are some of the criminal defence strategies that every resident in Sydney must know. So, if you get stuck in a case and don’t know what to do, you must know that you still have your rights as a resident of Sydney. Moreover, the top defences in criminal cases can always come to your rescue. A good lawyer always knows how to defend your case in your best interest.
FAQs
-
1. What is the most common defence used in Sydney criminal cases?
Depending on the type of cases, self-defence, Mens Rea, Duress or Coercion, and insanity or mental capacity defences are commonly used in criminal cases in Sydney.
-
2. Can I use self-defence to defend someone else?
Yes, self-defence can be used to defend themselves or another person.
-
3. What happens if I claim a lack of intent in my case?
If you claim lack of intent, you will have to establish that the criminal act was a result of a reasonable and an honest mistake.
-
4. How does the insanity defence work in Sydney?
The insanity defence works if the defendant can prove that they were not in the right mental state which made them lose the capacity to know what they were doing.
-
5. Is duress a valid defence for all types of crimes?
No, duress cannot be used as a valid defence for all types of crimes. It can only be used for serious crimes such as attempted murder, murder or any type of reason.